AI, Vol. 4, Pages 844-874: Anthropocentrism and Environmental Wellbeing in AI Ethics Standards: A Scoping Review and Discussion

As AI deployment has broadened, so too has an awareness for the ethical implications and problems that may ensue from this deployment. In response, groups across multiple domains have issued AI ethics standards that rely on vague, high-level principles to find consensus. One such high-level principle that is common across the AI landscape is ‘human-centredness’, though oftentimes it is applied without due investigation into its merits and limitations and without a clear, common definition. This paper undertakes a scoping review of AI ethics standards to examine the commitment to ‘human-centredness’ and how this commitment interacts with other ethical concerns, namely, concerns for nonhumans animals and environmental wellbeing. We found that human-centred AI ethics standards tend to prioritise humans over nonhumans more so than nonhuman-centred standards. A critical analysis of our findings suggests that a commitment to human-centredness within AI ethics standards accords with the definition of anthropocentrism in moral philosophy: that humans have, at least, more intrinsic moral value than nonhumans. We consider some of the limitations of anthropocentric AI ethics, which include permitting harm to the environment and animals and undermining the stability of ecosystems.

Apr 23, 2024 - 22:49
 0  112
AI, Vol. 4, Pages 844-874: Anthropocentrism and Environmental Wellbeing in AI Ethics Standards: A Scoping Review and Discussion

AI, Vol. 4, Pages 844-874: Anthropocentrism and Environmental Wellbeing in AI Ethics Standards: A Scoping Review and Discussion

AI doi: 10.3390/ai4040043

Authors: Eryn Rigley Adriane Chapman Christine Evers Will McNeill

As AI deployment has broadened, so too has an awareness for the ethical implications and problems that may ensue from this deployment. In response, groups across multiple domains have issued AI ethics standards that rely on vague, high-level principles to find consensus. One such high-level principle that is common across the AI landscape is ‘human-centredness’, though oftentimes it is applied without due investigation into its merits and limitations and without a clear, common definition. This paper undertakes a scoping review of AI ethics standards to examine the commitment to ‘human-centredness’ and how this commitment interacts with other ethical concerns, namely, concerns for nonhumans animals and environmental wellbeing. We found that human-centred AI ethics standards tend to prioritise humans over nonhumans more so than nonhuman-centred standards. A critical analysis of our findings suggests that a commitment to human-centredness within AI ethics standards accords with the definition of anthropocentrism in moral philosophy: that humans have, at least, more intrinsic moral value than nonhumans. We consider some of the limitations of anthropocentric AI ethics, which include permitting harm to the environment and animals and undermining the stability of ecosystems.

What's Your Reaction?

like

dislike

love

funny

angry

sad

wow

Lema Kefyalew Studying a Ph.D. in Civil Engineering (Hydraulic Engineering). Studying Master of Project Management (MPM). Graduated with MSc in Civil Engineering (Hydraulic Engineering). Followed a 12 month Software Engineering program at ALX_Africa (Holberton school). Graduated with BA degree in Management. Graduated with BSc degree in Civil Engineering.